rent vs buy · mumbai signature

your bandra rent vs your bandra emi.

The Mumbai property question. Not "is buying always better" (it isn't) — but: over your specific time horizon, do you end up richer renting + investing the difference, or buying + owning? The math is opinionated. Run the numbers.

● live · updates as you slidenet wealth comparison
rent · today
monthly rent
₹80,000
₹10k₹5L
rent escalation per year
6.0%
0%12%
buy · property
property price
₹2.5 cr
₹50L₹20cr
down payment
20%
10%60%
loan rate
8.5%
6%12%
loan tenure
20 yrs
530
assumptions
property appreciation/year
5.0%
0%12%
alternative MF return (rent + invest)
12.0%
5%18%
time horizon
10 yrs
130
The numbers are opinionated. Mumbai property appreciation has run ~3-6% real (above inflation) historically. Equity MFs ~10-14%. If MF beats appreciation + your loan rate is reasonable + horizon is short — renting often wins. Long horizons + low loan rates favour buying.
verdict at 10 years
renting wins
by ₹85.4 L net wealth
net wealth = ending assets minus outstanding obligations
→ buyer net wealth at end
₹2.65 cr
→ renter net wealth at end
₹3.50 cr
monthly EMI
₹1,73,634
down payment
₹50,00,000
total rent paid over horizon
₹1.27 cr
or just talk to archita directly.

you've run the numbers. now run them by archita.

Leave an email or a number — either one works — and Archita will follow up with a plain-English read on what these figures mean for you. No spam. No drip campaigns.

the boring math behind it

three honest answers.

how the comparison works.

Buyer at end of horizon: Owns property worth (price × appreciation^years), minus any outstanding loan if tenure > horizon. Renter at end of horizon: Has invested the down payment + the monthly difference (EMI − rent) in mutual funds at the assumed return.

Both started with the same money. Whoever has higher net wealth at the end wins. This isn't about lifestyle — that's a separate decision. This is purely the financial math.

what the calculator doesn't count.

Stamp duty + registration (~6%), maintenance (~₹50-150/sqft annually in Mumbai), brokerage on resale, mental cost of property hassle, the lifestyle freedom of renting (move closer to a new job, downsize when kids leave). The opposite: pride of ownership, security, ability to renovate, intergenerational wealth.

Most of these don't show up in a calculator. They should show up in your decision.

when does buying win?

Generally: long horizons (15+ years), reasonable loan rates (under 8%), high property appreciation areas, and when you're done moving. Buying becomes especially compelling when you would have rented for 20+ years anyway.

Renting usually wins when: short horizons (under 7 years), high property prices relative to rent, high alternative returns. Talk to Archita for a personalized opinion.

tools shelf
try another calculator.
see all 14 calculators →